The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
These groupings are based on how the rest of the team performed and in comparison to what they are capable of doing from the regular season’s performances.
The Good
- Steve Yzerman: He may only have had 4 assists in the four games he played this series and a -2 rating, he was out there working harder than the rest of the team in a desperate attempt to reach the second round. A torn rib muscle (ouch) sidelined him for Game #4 and Game #5. Most people expect him to retire in the next week or two; Wings fans hope he plays for one more season. If he does retire, I had the honor to watch him play in his last game at the Joe (Sunday, Game #2) since he did not play the last time the Wings were at the Joe, Game #5.
“You’re so wrapped up in the game, and then they score with a minute to go, I don’t really have a whole lot of thoughts other than, it just came to a quick end,” said Yzerman, who turns 41 next week and is the longest-serving captain in NHL history. “As far as my personal situation, it’s best to wait a few days, then I can pretty much make a quick decision.”It’s amazing that such a long career — 22 seasons, all in Detroit — actually could end so quickly. The spirit is always willing but Yzerman’s body, ravaged by injury and time, has betrayed him often, and that’s likely to be the deciding factor.
- Henrik Zetterberg: Hank had twice as many goals as the second highest Detroit goal scorer with 6 goals. He had 2 PIM, 0 assists, a -2 rating, and four power play goals. Zetterberg appeared to be one of the few who saw Yzerman’s vision and played at that same level. Whenever Yzerman retires, I would really consider making this guy the new captain.- Robert Lang: Sure he may not have been all that amazing during the regular season, but he’s one of the few Wings who actually picked up their play. He had three goals and three assists (6 points), 2 PIM, and -2 rating. Two of his goals came while on the power play. He also won 55% of his face-offs.
- Kris Draper: Draper is never going to lead the team in scoring, that’s not his purpose on this team. He may not have earned a single point this series, but was one of five players to actually have a + rating (Draper: +3). And in the elimination game, Draper was out there grinding away.
- Kirk Maltby: I actually noticed Maltby in the postseason. He scored two goals in Game #1, including the game winning goal in 2OT. He also had one assist for three total points this series. Like Draper, he was out there trying to generate chances.
- Chris Chelios: How is this 44 year old defenseman playing better defense than guys half his age? He played with more passion and just plain better skill than many of the other defensemen. He had zero points, 6 PIM, and a +2 rating.
The Bad
- Pavel Datsyuk: What is with Datsyuk in the postseason? I realize he had an injury and needed to catch up, but not even one little goal? Datsyuk got three assists in the five games he played. He had 0 PIM and a 0 +/- rating. Aside from some decent scoring chances and nice set up plays to Zetterberg (who would then score), Datsyuk wasn’t so hot this series. When you lead your team in points, I expect at least one goal in the playoffs.
- Nick Lidstrom: What happened to Lidstrom, Mr. Norris? After a fantastic year with some high offensive numbers, Lidstrom gets two points (one goal, one assist), 2 PIM, and a -4 rating. -4! His one goal (the controversial “pick” goal) came on the power play and was also the game winning goal.
- Mathieu Schneider: Surprisingly (at least in my opinion) was the fact that one of our defenseman actually led the team in points this series. Schneider had 8 points (1 goal, 7 assists). He also had 6 PIM and a -1 rating. He didn’t look too sharp this series; I’m not sure how much had to do with just returning from a groin injury that looked like it hadn’t even healed yet.
“We came out and did the things in the third period we didn’t want to do,” defenseman Mathieu Schneider said. “We didn’t play well enough to win. We put ourselves in this position. The only thing that would have made this a successful season was to win the Stanley Cup.”
- Manny Legace: Ah yes, the goaltender always gets blamed upon for the loss. Well, I don’t think Legace was the primary reason for our loss (our team just had a total and complete meltdown). He played decent and even had some strong saves (as well as allowing some pathetic goals). But we needed him to be great. It’s looking like Legace can’t handle the pressure of being the starting goaltender in the playoffs. Plus his constant whining about his teammates did not help the matter. In this series, Legace had a 2.65 GAA and a .884 save percentage. His opponent’s goalie, Dwayne Roloson, played these six games and ended with a 2.50 GAA and a .929 save percentage.
Manny Legace, who took the defeat hard in his first playoffs as a No. 1 goalie, summed up his mood, and possibly some of his teammates. “I feel like going out and hanging myself,” Legace said. “I really feel hollow inside.”On the winning goal, Legace said, “I didn’t even see (Hemsky). I thought it was a one-and-one and (Samsonov) threw it across and bang, he was there.”
- Brendan Shanahan: For having so much experience and actually reviving his game in the regular season, what happened? He had 40+ goals during this season and could only manage one goal and one assist in this playoff series. I wonder what he’ll do this off-season: retire? Or will Holland offer a significantly reduced contract?
“We were in such control, and then to give it away like that, it’s just embarrassing,” Brendan Shanahan said. “It summed up the whole series. We were playing great hockey, playing great hockey, and then it was a 6-7 minute collapse. Who has an answer for that?”
The Ugly
- Jason Williams: He had two points this series (1 goal, 1 assist) and that’s all the good he did in the past six games. I like the guy, I’ve personally interviewed him and whatnot. But he had so many errors (-3 rating) that really impacted the game and series. His stupid penalty caused a power play allowing the Oilers to tie it up in the elimination game. The Wings need to get rid of him - I don’t care if we have to send him to Grand Rapids, we cannot afford his mistakes and he has too many of them.- Andreas Lilja: He had one assist and a -4 rating. Yikes. His poor defensive coverage resulted in numerous goals at critical points in the game. Unfortunately, Holland recently signed him to a 2 year, 2 million dollar deal. I don’t have much else to say aside from yikes.
- Mikael Samuelsson: He’s been streaky all year and then the Wings go and sign him to a bloody three year deal! He had one assist, -1 rating, and 6 PIM (4 of which came in the elimination game). Why did Holland not wait until the postseason to sign Samuelsson to a contract? Why?
Mediocre
I’m not going to detail this guys; they weren’t bad/ugly but they weren’t good either.
- Tomas Holmstrom (3 points, 6 PIM, -1 rating)
- Johan Franzen (3 points, 4 PIM, 0 rating)
- Niklas Kronwall (3 points, 2 PIM, 0 rating)
- Dan Cleary (1 point, 6 PIM, +2 rating)
- Brett Lebda (0 points, 4 PIM, +3 rating)
+/- Rating
Only five Detroit players actually had a + rating in this series: Draper, Maltby, Chelios, Lebda, and Cleary.
Thank You
I’d like to thank all my readers for checking out my blog, especially during the postseason. I enjoy writing for BtJ and I plan to continue doing so over the summer and into the 2006-2007 regular season. I appreciated your comments on games, signings, and other random stuff I have posted on in the past.
I will not have internet connection while I’m in Cincinnati for surgery. So until I return home and feel up to posting (either Thursday night or later), there will be no further updates on this blog. Please check out Abel to Yzerman, On the Wings, and Kukla’s Korner for any Wings updates or playoff reactions during the next week. Also check out the blogs that I’ve linked to on the right side of this page for comments on playoff action around the league. Thanks again!
Related Posts
One Response to “The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly”
Leave a Reply
December 31st, 2006 at 3:43 pm
[…] Then in April, the playoffs happened. What could have been a wonderful joyous time for the league’s best (in the regular season) became “The Punch in the Face.” If you’re an Oilers fan, you can gloat at how idiotic my prediction turned out to be for the series (and I wasn’t alone). And for those of you who want to revel in the glory of an Oilers’ series win or want to remind yourselves of the agony experienced by Wings fans, you can check out my postgame recollections of Game #1, Game #2, Game #3 (a liveblog of the game), Game #4, Game #5, and Game #6. Then I broke down the playoff series with the Wings version of the Good, Bad, and Ugly. […]